Feedback System Opinions Needed!

Post by **Diablo0** » Fri Aug 25, 2006 11:40 pm

Most of you are unaware but recenly we have tried to find a feedback system for phpBB to aid in the process of leaving feedback for members that do buy and sell items on here.

In searching for one I did find one that works great there is only one problem which I will mention later.

With the feedback system, a seller posts up an item they have for sale, people discuss and when the item sells the seller clicks a finalize button, selects the user that purchased the item or types in a user if they were not registered on here. A Feedback Bot then locks the thread to prevent any later reseructions asking if the item was sold, posts in the thread stating who the item was sold to, and PMs both parties notifying them that the sale has finalized and provides a link to leave feedback for each other. Beside each pesons name and viewable in their profile is a link to show how much positive feedback each member has which can be clicked and viewed just like with eBay displaying how many positives, negatives, and neutrals have been left in the past 1, 6, and 12 months along with all feedback comments left by members that have purchased or sold to them. In addition to leaving feedback for someone you are also able to leave a reponse to someone that leaves feedback for you. So if someone were to leave you a negative feedback you would be able to respond to that negative with a short explanation of your side of the story.... just like eBay.

Sound good?

Here's the down side to the system though that I've been trying to get around but so far haven't found an easy way. If you have 5 items to sell, each item would need to be listed under it's own thread. If you had 20 items you wanted to get rid of, that means you'd need to make 20 threads for each item instead of just one thread listing the 20 items you want to sell. Follow me?

So here's my question... how many would be okay with this? I like the idea of being able to leave more of a eBay style feedback but not sure how many of you, the members, accept such a feedback system having to make individual threads for each item to be sold?

Need some input... thanks!

SlvrACR · Post by **SlvrACR** » Fri Aug 25, 2006 11:55 pm

I like the way SRTforums has there feedback but Im not sure if it would work here.

Post by **Diablo0** » Fri Aug 25, 2006 11:58 pm

Yeah, I've been searching high and low for something just like that and this is as close as I've found. It's nearly identical to that but the coder that made this one went a little overboard and made it too complicated.

CA180 · Post by **CA180** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 12:08 am

i like the idea of being able to leave feedback that would be more visible to all forum members. It seems to me that the current section for feedback is effective... but some people might overlook that which has been posted by others.

The issue of having to open different threads, i believe, would cause quite a dilema. You may forget what one person may be selling, you would have to look at the many different threads to find what you are looking for, and it may become an all around nuisance.

I havent been here on 2gn long enough to get a feel for any kind of real issues with the way the for sale, wtb, and feedback sections are run. But seems to me that when you have a good thing, you dont replace it with something else.... unless its exactly what you want.

just my opinion though, to each their own...

Post by **Diablo0** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 12:17 am

The only real problem we have right now is if Person A posts a negative about say Person B, obviously Person B will typically respond back to Person A to defend their side of the story. The problem however is that the thread typically continues on and on as one big argument instead of just letting it be where something such as a feedback system will generally only allow you to post up one little comment to which the other person can respond and that is the end of it. No big threads with a back and forth arguement about who is right or wrong, ect.

It doesnt' happen very often but every now and then it does come up and cause quite a stir since people do take their feedback seriously...

OB · Post by OB » Sat Aug 26, 2006 12:32 am

I dont think the system we have now is all that bad. Sure its primitive, but its not like this is 2gncarpartsales.com; selling/buying only takes up like 10% of what happens on 2gn, so IMO its not a huge deal. but if u guys think its a good idea then im all for it.

Frizbe · Post by **Frizbe** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 2:29 am

Diablo0 wrote:Here's the down side to the system though that I've been trying to get around but so far haven't found an easy way. If you have 5 items to sell, each item would need to be listed under it's own thread. If you had 20 items you wanted to get rid of, that means you'd need to make 20 threads for each item instead of just one thread listing the 20 items you want to sell. Follow me?

Post Count FTW!!!!!!!!

Post by **Diablo0** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 2:30 am

Already though off and the post count increases would be disabled for the for sale boards

Frizbe · Post by **Frizbe** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 2:33 am

Diablo0 wrote:Already though off and the post count increases would be disabled for the for sale boards

I would hope so, but I didn't read anywhere that it would be. So.... I came to that conclusion.

LowNSlow · Post by **LowNSlow** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 8:16 am

Sounds like a bad ass feedback system.

I'd go for it.. who cares if you got to make 5 posts for 5 different items. The for sale section isn't used by thousands and thousands... so it wouldn't be THAT cluttered.

atom · Post by **atom** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 8:32 am

Yeah thats a major con but i so the pros outweigh it just a tad. I vote to go for it.

Nick Drake · Post by **Nick Drake** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 12:52 pm

That's not such a bad con, I mean it would be nice to just skim the forum and see exactly what's for sale, not just "Lots of parts!".

Either way it's a good idea.

Panhead · Post by **Panhead** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 1:11 pm

i like the itrader system on srtforums. i also know a couple sites that have it. just my 02.

kc2005ptgt · Post by **kc2005ptgt** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 2:39 pm

hmmm - i like the idea also of the 1 part 1 sale posts - mainly because of what was just stated - now I can skim, not have to look at EVERY thread. It can be more specific on the title and stuff too.

FS: blah blah

Woudl be nice, because now I know that poster A has blah blah for sale. Not "tons of stuff!" If you have 20 items to sell, or a car to part out, maybe you can get a whole new forum topic for that? Like a "Parting Car FORUM" or something.

CA180 · Post by **CA180** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 3:09 pm

^well, if you put it like that... i would agree

scneonchic · Post by **scneonchic** » Sat Aug 26, 2006 4:21 pm

I think the one thread for one item thing is a good idea. I find it hard to search through all the threads when all someone says is "neon parts" or "engine parts". I would like it to be more specific.

J-Villa · Post by **J-Villa** » Sun Aug 27, 2006 1:52 am

i personally liked the system we tried out...i think it would work out good...plus i think the one item per thread is another good idea....just sucks if you are tryin to part out a whole car though haha....

Post by **Diablo0** » Sun Aug 27, 2006 1:55 am

J-Villa wrote:i personally liked the system we tried out...i think it would work out good...plus i think the one item per thread is another good idea....just sucks if you are tryin to part out a whole car though haha....

Yah, that's what I'm worried about. If I install it I'm afraid it'll be like the auction system and no one will use it. If people are serious about it and actually take the time to list all their future parts out in individual threads then I've got no problem putting it on here. I just don't want to install it and not have anyone use it.

Still looking for everyones opinion on this. I know there are more active members than this

SILVER-ES · Post by **SILVER-ES** » Sun Aug 27, 2006 2:02 am

Blah, blah, blah.

2003silverneonsxt · Post by **2003silverneonsxt** » Sun Aug 27, 2006 1:23 pm

is all the current feedback going to be transferable into the new system or is everyone starting with a clean slate?

thats my only question

GO FOR IT!

Nick Drake · Post by **Nick Drake** » Sun Aug 27, 2006 1:23 pm

About the auction, I'd personally use it a lot more if I remembered it existed when I was on the forums. It'd need it's own forum if it were to become successful, not just a little icon at the top. That's just me though. As long as you keep the For Sale's in their own forum I'm sure they'd survive.

J-Villa · Post by **J-Villa** » Sun Aug 27, 2006 1:33 pm

the old feedback would just become a locked forum...so people can view them...but there is no way to transfer the old to the knew....

Post by **Diablo0** » Wed Aug 30, 2006 1:27 am

So I take it everyone is game to try it out? If so I'll add it sometime next week.

J-Villa · Post by **J-Villa** » Wed Aug 30, 2006 1:28 am

i'm game for the new system...even though i won't have a job any more

lol

Post by **Diablo0** » Wed Aug 30, 2006 1:36 am

You'll have a job

BlackRoseRacing · Post by **BlackRoseRacing** » Wed Aug 30, 2006 7:25 am

J-Villa wrote:i'm game for the new system...even though i won't have a job any more lol

^^^
My car needs a bath

2GN.ORG

Feedback System Opinions Needed!

Feedback System Opinions Needed!

Re: Feedback System Opinions Needed!