What I hope to be a *civil* discussion about ethics...
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2007 2:13 pm
This post isn't intended to contain a flame war, but to open up what I think is a larger issue that really bothers me. It began with something as small as a bumper sticker, but for me it is much more than that. So I will spell it all out, civilly, without malice, and without haste. I will not pass personal judgements, nor will I insult, but I would hope that a similar lack of bravado is maintained here. I am not in control of your personal standards, each and every one of you. That is your own responsibily. With that said...
I have given this bumper sticker thing much thought, and after that, this is how I feel about it all.
Normally I would agree with those of you who think it’s wrong to slap a sticker on something, however easy or not it is to remove. But this, to me, isn’t a normal situation.
For me this concerns American values, and, I suppose, that includes most of North America (Canada), with perhaps the exception of Quebec, since they seem to strive to be apart from North American culture, for better or worse.
I reiterate once again, I never concerned myself with people parking weird in wide open areas. I was talking about someone parking ridiculous just because they believe that they have the right to two spaces. But after much thinking, I realize that for me, this is something greater than parking crooked intentionally.
This has to do with decency, and with standards. I’m 32, as someone has so pointed out, so I can remember a time when things were different. I remember when kids were kept back a grade when they failed. I remember when stuff from the store came without safety caps and hermetic seals because no one had yet tried to poison a perfect stranger. And I remember when major department stores were in English.
And I remember when people stopped for red lights, and running one was a big deal. Now four or five run one. I’m not talking about in urban areas where the busy streets have signals with no protected left turn arrow. I mean where the arrow is there, but some people feel they are above everyone else and can go anyways.
And I remember when taking up two spaces was considered taboo, and was rarely seen, because most people would have been embarrassed to do so. And it’s not like they had tiny cars back then.
I guess what bothers me is that these are things that *should* bother other people, and I suppose do indeed bother them, but, much like the gas prices, most people sit back at their computers, or on their lunch breaks, or at the bar, and just talk about it, and do nothing. They don’t really lay the guilt and shame on those who take advantage, so those who take advantage continue to do so, unchecked, and that encourages others with similarly-weak ethics. And the laws aren’t enacted nearly as tough as they used to be, because nobody has the initiative to fight for better laws. And anyways, if today’s society were culturally tougher on those who took advantage, the taboo would make the law unnecessary.
I am fully-aware, on the other side of this, that we emphasize a certain level of freedom in this nation, so I am not suggesting we create a law or taboo against everything. Not only that, but I also understand that two people can disagree and both feel they are equally right. However, I am not here to debate semantics, and there are obviously some things that are wrong, no matter how “right” the person thinks he or she is. Simply believing you are “right” doesn’t make you so. I am well aware this applies to myself, however I tend to feel that I am a reasonable judge of right and wrong.
Is it wrong to slap a sticker on a car? Or a flyer even? Usually, yes. But I feel it is worse to take advantage of things at the expense of others. It’s very un-American by the traditional definition, although sadly, it is becoming the new American attitude, replacing the old traditional values. To me, more and more it has sounded very egocentric, and basically saying through actions, “I can do what I want, and if you try to stop me, confront me, criticize me, or punish me for it, you are not only wrong, but I will stab you in the eye with my fork if I catch you.” Perhaps to some that might seem like an exaggeration, but we aren’t far from that now, and horrible things have often come from meager beginnings.
I have seen things change. I used to believe very much in “two wrongs don’t make a right”, but the law and society has begun to fail to keep decent the place I find myself in. Sure, there have always been places in the world where it was like this or worse, but on this continent, we have always strived to be above that. To respect ourselves by respecting [/i] others. Taking advantage of things at the expense of others is not respect. It disrespects society, and those who directly lose out, and finally, the self.
I personally feel that when this occurs, said person who has such disrespect has forfeited any respect returned. I have been called disrespectful for this attitude, but thinking about it now, it only strengthens my convictions.
Perhaps it isn’t worth the drama, or in some parts where there are seriously dangerous people, placing a sticker, or even a note as someone has suggested, is a bad idea. But perhaps someone needs to take a risk at their own expense, more often, and more people need to do something -- anything -- to give the message to those who would take advantage that their actions do not go unnoticed or especially unchallenged.
Would it be better if I stood there and personally confronted the offender? Perhaps. Would it do any good? NO. There is always the chance they will, by superior force, foil my effort to challenge them. That doesn’t make them right. In fact, it makes them barbaric, in the more subtle of meanings.
But a sticker… a note is easily discarded, even laughed at. A sticker demands attention, and no matter how upset someone gets over it… no matter how much they rationalize to themselves that they didn’t deserve it and thus nobody had a right to place it there… they know… THEY KNOW, with certainty, that it was NOT done with petty vandalism in mind, but to check the initial ethical failure. And nothing less could possibly have done that, and anything else would have been extreme.
Someone stated something very important in all this. If you don’t park like an idiot, then you have nothing to worry about. But the reality is, this should be true of ALL things in life. Consideration for others is so very important, especially when we are faced with ever-increasing population densities, and ever-increasing communication between peoples of all regions via internet and telephone. Respect IS important, but we cannot expect it in the face of our own disrespect. That would be having your cake, and eating it, too.
So am I disrespectful? In my opinion (and this includes this particular forum), NO. I am actually very respectful. I may change lanes often, but I give plenty of room, and signal ahead of time. I make certain to park like I should, whenever possible, even if it means re-parking. I don’t run red turn signals 99% of the time. If I accidentally cut someone off, I wave and apologize. If someone has been waiting at a driveway exit to merge, I graciously let them in, even though the jerk behind me is honking at me because five seconds later the light turned green. I still hold doors open for people. I treat foreigners with respect, even though I find it disrespectful to see (for example) Spanish included on major signs and literature (and I’m half Mexican, at that).
Some of you feel disrespected personally on here, but after closely reading what has been said this time and elsewhere, I have unfortunately determined that nobody was personally singled out by my comments. I say “unfortunately”, because it is also quite clear that isn’t the case in the other direction. It began with someone commenting rather rudely in the simple matter of discussing suspension modifications, where rather than respectfully disagreeing, somebody felt the need to insult. Of course, I should not have bitten that bait, but forum flaming is contagious, and also because perhaps it fell in line with the sentiments in this longwinded but (for me) very necessary post.
Regardless, it continued into this issue, and apparently some people felt the need to jump on said bandwagon. Sadly, it became quite personal, which was never my own intention. I’m glad I didn’t start the personal attacks, but I’m not glad it came to that. The truth is, I never meant anyone disrespect in a personal sense. As I said, I am very respectful. However…
I am very respectful, as I have explained earlier in this post... until I spot disrespect. Then, as far as I am concerned (and this came from years of contemplation), that person forfeits any respect I might have given them.
Sadly, I am beginning to believe that this is where things are going in society. Are my sentiments going to actually make a difference? I am beginning to believe they are not. However, if more people who feel the way I do actually take some kind of action, any kind, for that matter, then perhaps it will slow the decay a bit, or who knows, even move us in the right direction.
I was going to give the last ten stickers away, and say “eff’ it.” However, after writing all this, and really giving it thought, and knowing full well that the only damage one of these stickers could possibly cause is to someone’s pride, I kind of feel it’s my civic duty to keep a few with me, just in case I do indeed spot something way out of line. It is easy to say “I wouldn’t do that” when you don’t have the stickers, or when you aren’t there at the time. I used to say that, too. I’m just tired of sitting back and doing nothing. If it’s not the responsibility of the police (it is not), and other people refuse to make it undesirable socially, then someone has to do something about it.
And I think that is as best as I can put it, civilly, and with plenty of thought beforehand.
I do hope people comment on here, and I'm more than willing to listen to civil argument. A few of you know this by email. I feel that some of you had some good points, and this is more appropriate a place to voice them, same as with myself.
If you really don't have much to say, I can respect and even appreciate that, as this is a car forum, however I did place this in Off-Topic, and I typically feel that there is more to an auto enthusiast than his/her car.
I have given this bumper sticker thing much thought, and after that, this is how I feel about it all.
Normally I would agree with those of you who think it’s wrong to slap a sticker on something, however easy or not it is to remove. But this, to me, isn’t a normal situation.
For me this concerns American values, and, I suppose, that includes most of North America (Canada), with perhaps the exception of Quebec, since they seem to strive to be apart from North American culture, for better or worse.
I reiterate once again, I never concerned myself with people parking weird in wide open areas. I was talking about someone parking ridiculous just because they believe that they have the right to two spaces. But after much thinking, I realize that for me, this is something greater than parking crooked intentionally.
This has to do with decency, and with standards. I’m 32, as someone has so pointed out, so I can remember a time when things were different. I remember when kids were kept back a grade when they failed. I remember when stuff from the store came without safety caps and hermetic seals because no one had yet tried to poison a perfect stranger. And I remember when major department stores were in English.
And I remember when people stopped for red lights, and running one was a big deal. Now four or five run one. I’m not talking about in urban areas where the busy streets have signals with no protected left turn arrow. I mean where the arrow is there, but some people feel they are above everyone else and can go anyways.
And I remember when taking up two spaces was considered taboo, and was rarely seen, because most people would have been embarrassed to do so. And it’s not like they had tiny cars back then.
I guess what bothers me is that these are things that *should* bother other people, and I suppose do indeed bother them, but, much like the gas prices, most people sit back at their computers, or on their lunch breaks, or at the bar, and just talk about it, and do nothing. They don’t really lay the guilt and shame on those who take advantage, so those who take advantage continue to do so, unchecked, and that encourages others with similarly-weak ethics. And the laws aren’t enacted nearly as tough as they used to be, because nobody has the initiative to fight for better laws. And anyways, if today’s society were culturally tougher on those who took advantage, the taboo would make the law unnecessary.
I am fully-aware, on the other side of this, that we emphasize a certain level of freedom in this nation, so I am not suggesting we create a law or taboo against everything. Not only that, but I also understand that two people can disagree and both feel they are equally right. However, I am not here to debate semantics, and there are obviously some things that are wrong, no matter how “right” the person thinks he or she is. Simply believing you are “right” doesn’t make you so. I am well aware this applies to myself, however I tend to feel that I am a reasonable judge of right and wrong.
Is it wrong to slap a sticker on a car? Or a flyer even? Usually, yes. But I feel it is worse to take advantage of things at the expense of others. It’s very un-American by the traditional definition, although sadly, it is becoming the new American attitude, replacing the old traditional values. To me, more and more it has sounded very egocentric, and basically saying through actions, “I can do what I want, and if you try to stop me, confront me, criticize me, or punish me for it, you are not only wrong, but I will stab you in the eye with my fork if I catch you.” Perhaps to some that might seem like an exaggeration, but we aren’t far from that now, and horrible things have often come from meager beginnings.
I have seen things change. I used to believe very much in “two wrongs don’t make a right”, but the law and society has begun to fail to keep decent the place I find myself in. Sure, there have always been places in the world where it was like this or worse, but on this continent, we have always strived to be above that. To respect ourselves by respecting [/i] others. Taking advantage of things at the expense of others is not respect. It disrespects society, and those who directly lose out, and finally, the self.
I personally feel that when this occurs, said person who has such disrespect has forfeited any respect returned. I have been called disrespectful for this attitude, but thinking about it now, it only strengthens my convictions.
Perhaps it isn’t worth the drama, or in some parts where there are seriously dangerous people, placing a sticker, or even a note as someone has suggested, is a bad idea. But perhaps someone needs to take a risk at their own expense, more often, and more people need to do something -- anything -- to give the message to those who would take advantage that their actions do not go unnoticed or especially unchallenged.
Would it be better if I stood there and personally confronted the offender? Perhaps. Would it do any good? NO. There is always the chance they will, by superior force, foil my effort to challenge them. That doesn’t make them right. In fact, it makes them barbaric, in the more subtle of meanings.
But a sticker… a note is easily discarded, even laughed at. A sticker demands attention, and no matter how upset someone gets over it… no matter how much they rationalize to themselves that they didn’t deserve it and thus nobody had a right to place it there… they know… THEY KNOW, with certainty, that it was NOT done with petty vandalism in mind, but to check the initial ethical failure. And nothing less could possibly have done that, and anything else would have been extreme.
Someone stated something very important in all this. If you don’t park like an idiot, then you have nothing to worry about. But the reality is, this should be true of ALL things in life. Consideration for others is so very important, especially when we are faced with ever-increasing population densities, and ever-increasing communication between peoples of all regions via internet and telephone. Respect IS important, but we cannot expect it in the face of our own disrespect. That would be having your cake, and eating it, too.
So am I disrespectful? In my opinion (and this includes this particular forum), NO. I am actually very respectful. I may change lanes often, but I give plenty of room, and signal ahead of time. I make certain to park like I should, whenever possible, even if it means re-parking. I don’t run red turn signals 99% of the time. If I accidentally cut someone off, I wave and apologize. If someone has been waiting at a driveway exit to merge, I graciously let them in, even though the jerk behind me is honking at me because five seconds later the light turned green. I still hold doors open for people. I treat foreigners with respect, even though I find it disrespectful to see (for example) Spanish included on major signs and literature (and I’m half Mexican, at that).
Some of you feel disrespected personally on here, but after closely reading what has been said this time and elsewhere, I have unfortunately determined that nobody was personally singled out by my comments. I say “unfortunately”, because it is also quite clear that isn’t the case in the other direction. It began with someone commenting rather rudely in the simple matter of discussing suspension modifications, where rather than respectfully disagreeing, somebody felt the need to insult. Of course, I should not have bitten that bait, but forum flaming is contagious, and also because perhaps it fell in line with the sentiments in this longwinded but (for me) very necessary post.
Regardless, it continued into this issue, and apparently some people felt the need to jump on said bandwagon. Sadly, it became quite personal, which was never my own intention. I’m glad I didn’t start the personal attacks, but I’m not glad it came to that. The truth is, I never meant anyone disrespect in a personal sense. As I said, I am very respectful. However…
I am very respectful, as I have explained earlier in this post... until I spot disrespect. Then, as far as I am concerned (and this came from years of contemplation), that person forfeits any respect I might have given them.
Sadly, I am beginning to believe that this is where things are going in society. Are my sentiments going to actually make a difference? I am beginning to believe they are not. However, if more people who feel the way I do actually take some kind of action, any kind, for that matter, then perhaps it will slow the decay a bit, or who knows, even move us in the right direction.
I was going to give the last ten stickers away, and say “eff’ it.” However, after writing all this, and really giving it thought, and knowing full well that the only damage one of these stickers could possibly cause is to someone’s pride, I kind of feel it’s my civic duty to keep a few with me, just in case I do indeed spot something way out of line. It is easy to say “I wouldn’t do that” when you don’t have the stickers, or when you aren’t there at the time. I used to say that, too. I’m just tired of sitting back and doing nothing. If it’s not the responsibility of the police (it is not), and other people refuse to make it undesirable socially, then someone has to do something about it.
And I think that is as best as I can put it, civilly, and with plenty of thought beforehand.
I do hope people comment on here, and I'm more than willing to listen to civil argument. A few of you know this by email. I feel that some of you had some good points, and this is more appropriate a place to voice them, same as with myself.
If you really don't have much to say, I can respect and even appreciate that, as this is a car forum, however I did place this in Off-Topic, and I typically feel that there is more to an auto enthusiast than his/her car.